The Iron Trial by Holly Black

a review by Vanessa , in the genre(s) Fantasy . Book published by Scholastic in September 2014

The Iron Trial focuses on the students of the Magisterium, an academy for those with magic. In this first book, a new student, Callum Hunt comes to the Magisterium against his will—but is it because he is destined to be a powerful magician, or is the truth more twisted than that?

Well, let me just answer that very obvious (and rhetorical) question: the truth is, absolutely, more twisted than that. I read The Iron Trial within two days—it’s a quick read. The book kept me curious, though the plot followed a fairly predictable path until the big twist at the very end (even though wasn’t really that shocking). I’ve always loved Black and Clare’s writing, even if it isn’t always great classic literature. The Iron Trial is what it is—a fun, quick, enjoyable read.

When I checked the book out on Goodreads, I it getting a lot of flak for being a Harry Potter ripoff (at least that’s what people are guessing, as it isn’t out yet. I was lucky enough to get an Advance Reader copy in exchange for this review). And okay, Sure, if you DIG REALLY DEEPLY, you can claim that it’s similar to Harry Potter. Main character fights against evil. Girl and boy best friends. He goes to magic school.

But for me, the similarities end there (and, let’s be honest, it just isn’t fair to the book to compare it to Harry Potter). There is no way that anyone is going to be able to write about magic schools without them being compared to Harry Potter, and that in no way devalues the book.

I enjoyed the characters. The main character, Callum (referred to as Call), is intriguing in his magic and character. Tamara, Callum’s friend, seems irritating and pompous at first, but as layers are gradually peeled back we discover that she is much more than that. Aaron, who seems to be the golden child, is interesting and complex. Their teacher, Master Rufus, is enigmatic in his actions (for example, his initial teachings involved sifting sand while other students learned how to really use magic, but the focus they learned proved invaluable).

My favorite part of the novel—that I am sure will continue into the following books—is the line drawn between good and evil and how very, very fuzzy it is. It’s one of my favorite book themes, and The Iron Trial does not disappoint on that end. I look forward to reading the following books and seeing where Clare and Black take that vein

In short, if you’re looking for a quick, good, entertaining YA read, why not pick up The Iron Trial?

Written on 3rd September 2014 by . '.$details->rating .' Star Rating

A Message from SFBook

SFBook is entirely funded by Ant including hosting, development and any other costs.

If you enjoy the site please consider a small donation towards the cost of the upkeep and development of SFBook.

The Iron Trial, a novel by Holly Black

Book Details

  • The Iron Trial
  • Publisher: Scholastic
  • ISBN: 978-0545522250
  • Published:
  • Pages: 320
  • Format reviewed: Hardback
  • Review date: 03/09/2014
  • Language: English
  • Age Range: 15-